I am not a music critic any more than I am a gastronome.
Yet this is the internet, and I may expound as I please.
****************************************
The
GJSO presented the following tonight:
"Made In America" by contemporary composer
Joan Tower (who also conducted the piece)
"Huapango" by Jose Pablo Moncayo
"Estrellita" by Manuel Ponce
"Violin Concerto in D Major" by Johannes Brahms; guest violinist
Linda Wang Two of the pieces, Huapango and the Brahms, were familiar to me. The other two were not. I think I probably would've enjoyed the "Made In America" piece a lot more had I been more familiar with it. In addition, the piece apparently called for fewer orchestra members than usual, as once it was over 15 or so more people joined the members already on stage. To me it often seemed that the woodwinds/brass were significantly overpowering the strings, possibly due to the limited number of performers. This continued at times throughout the night but was more prominent with the first piece. I felt that it kept the orchestra from blending well. With modern music, it is imperative that everyone be in tune, on time, and blend well or it sounds more aleatoric than the composer intended. I didn't often feel that the orchestra was comfortable with the piece.
The Huapango was fun, well-played, and obviously one the orchestra felt quite comfortable with.
The Estrellita was nice as well. According to the program notes, it's quite a famous melody but it was new to me.
And then the Brahms. I love this concerto, and Ms. Wang did a fabulous job. There's something about hearing a piece live that you've only previously heard recorded. I caught plenty of musical nuances that had escaped my ears before. Overall it was an enjoyable experience, with just a few quibbles.
Again, the woodwind/brass had difficulty staying under the strings at times. I honestly think this has a lot to do with the fact that they are up on risers while the strings are arranged below them. In my opinion, they should be on the same level to keep their sound from sailing over the string section and hitting the audience. Perhaps an acoustic tile on the ground in front of each horn as well? I could really tell that the winds were doing their best to be quiet and subtle, but it just didn't work.
And the oboes, well, I'm extra critical of them because that's my instrument. They improved throughout the concert but were often slightly out of tune and the sound wasn't clear; note attacks were less than crisp. They had some gorgeous moments but plenty of not-so-gorgeous.
But at least they were better than the second violins. :)
Overall, not bad for a free ticket from Casey's work.